The (audit) adjustment bureau

A major sales tax audit adjustment hit cities across the state of Texas in February. Chad and Patrick talk about the adjustment and some issues it highlighted. We follow up with a discussion on the recent performance of downtowns versus power centers, and the under-appreciated role that downtowns play in differentiating your city.

0:12 Chad
So I just watched an episode of Fresh Prince-
0:14 Patrick
Of Bel-Air?
0:15 Chad
... where, yes, where they go back to Philly.
0:18 Patrick
Mm-hmm.
0:19 Chad
'Cause, you know, they live in LA, which is, like, the car-centric city.
0:22 Patrick
Mm-hmm.
0:23 Chad
So they go back to Philly, and everyone.... Like, Phil- Will's happy to go back, 'cause his mom lives there and whatnot.
0:29 Patrick
Yeah.
0:29 Chad
But everyone else is like, "Uh, I gotta go to Philly." You know, it's like, "Uh, trash city. Um, can't stay in the small house. I gotta go find, like, a five-star hotel." Anyway, after, like, a day or two, they kind of acclimate, and, like, Philip and Vivian, they have to run some errands, so they're just- they just go for a walk, walking around the neighborhood. They find a brunch spot. They find some interesting stores. They're just enjoying the city, right? And when they get back to the house, they're just so hap- so happy and content. Uh, it was just an interesting contrast between that environment that they were in, and then how they typically act when they're in LA. There's just so many episodes about traffic, and cars, and how, you know, awful all that is. But to have this sort of contrast, uh, and this sort of take on urbanism that I was not expecting in a random Fresh Prince episode, so it was kind of interesting.
1:24 Patrick
Have you ever been to Philadelphia?
1:26 Chad
I have been to Philadelphia, yes.
1:27 Patrick
It's actually a pretty nice city, downtown.
1:29 Chad
I like, I like it.
1:30 Patrick
It's very pretty. Uh, it's got-
1:31 Chad
It's one of the-
1:32 Patrick
... a really interesting mix-
1:33 Chad
... oldest, um, one of-
1:33 Patrick
- of old and new
1:34 Chad
... it's one of the oldest designed cities. The plan for Philly was from, like, the 1660s.
1:40 Patrick
Yeah. It's pretty-
1:41 Chad
Thomas Holmes, I believe.
1:43 Patrick
Wow!
1:44 Chad
You know that he originally planned the, like, central part of the city around four, like s- like, um, not central parks, but, like, four sort of anchor parks, like corner parks.
1:57 Patrick
Mm-hmm.
1:58 Chad
And then the rest of the grid was based around that. But he was expecting it to be one acre, like, estate homes.
2:05 Patrick
Do you know what a specialization in urban planning is? I, I-
2:10 Chad
Uh, s-
2:10 Patrick
... have that from Texas A&M, and I didn't know any of what you just said right there. It's funny to me that you are significantly more planning nerded than I am sometimes. But a specialization in planning basically just means, uh, I needed it for a resume, and I didn't actually get a minor, 'cause I was one class short. That's what it means.
2:29 Chad
Did you get your minor in history?
2:30 Patrick
No, I got my minor in business administration-
2:32 Chad
Business, okay
2:32 Patrick
... and accounting. Yeah.
2:33 Chad
Well, that's working out for you now.
2:35 Patrick
It worked out well, didn't it? Yeah. So, um, I feel like we need-
2:39 Chad
I mean-
2:39 Patrick
... to go ahead and do the intro, since this is probably all gonna make it on the podcast.
2:43 Chad
Okay. Well, g- that'll be an interesting way to just start-
2:46 Patrick
Yeah
2:46 Chad
... just talking about Fresh Prince.
2:47 Patrick
Let's, let's jump right into the intro.
2:49 Chad
Okay, well, h- having said all of that, welcome to ZacCast. Greetings, all of that jazz. I'm Chad. That's Patrick. Uh, this is your official podcast for local government nerdery. Uh, so I guess let's just... You wanna keep on going with that topic?
3:01 Patrick
Yeah, let's go.
3:02 Chad
What else do you want to do?
3:03 Patrick
Let's go. Are we going right into downtowns? I thought we were gonna talk about hair first, and then we'd jump into downtowns.
3:07 Chad
That's fine.
3:08 Patrick
Okay.
3:08 Chad
When you mentioned downtown, that's what I thought of, was this episode that I had just watched.
3:12 Patrick
Nice.
3:12 Chad
And, um, yeah, so... But the only reason that I... So you had, like, a planning specialization. My planning college-
3:20 Patrick
They don't actually call it that. I just had a professor who told me, "Yeah, just list it like that on your resume."
3:24 Chad
That's, that's fine.
3:25 Patrick
Yeah.
3:25 Chad
Lie, whatever. No one's gonna check it.
3:28 Patrick
Nobody checked it, and at this point, it doesn't matter anymore.
3:31 Chad
So, um, but, I mean, my knowledge is I, I actually don't really like planning. Um, I never did gr- like, coming into the field.
3:40 Patrick
Mm-hmm.
3:41 Chad
Like, we argued about the merits of zoning for a decade-
3:45 Patrick
Wow
3:45 Chad
... before, like, while we worked together. Um-
3:47 Patrick
You've finally come around on zoning, though, haven't you?
3:49 Chad
No, I actually like it less.
3:50 Patrick
Oh, wow, okay.
3:53 Chad
I think zoning is unconstitutional, and I think that there's a good chance that we might have Euclid versus Ambler overturned.
3:59 Patrick
Wow! Hey, hold o- hold on for a second so I can beep all that out. Ah.
4:03 Chad
All right, sorry, go ahead.
4:04 Patrick
Yeah.
4:04 Chad
So the problem with zoning is that, like, the idea behind, uh, like, public s- health and welfare-
4:12 Patrick
Mm-hmm
4:12 Chad
... like, that is a legitimate governmental interest, but what zoning actually is in practice is, has nothing to do with that. So-
4:22 Patrick
Okay
4:22 Chad
... what it has become is much more of a taking than any sort of, like, uh, public safety, health, and welfare, uh, instrument. That's just my opinion.
4:35 Patrick
Okay. This is a very interesting conversation. So, um, so-
4:43 Chad
Let's skip around then. T- tell me about your haircut story, and then we'll jump into the-
4:46 Patrick
All right, so then we'll go into downtowns. All right.
4:47 Chad
Yeah.
4:47 Patrick
I'm gonna have to come back to that.
4:48 Chad
We're, we're, we're gonna skip all over... Like, this is gonna be one of the most schizophrenic episodes that we've had, 'cause-
4:52 Patrick
It's true
4:53 Chad
... starting with, uh, like, halfway into a conversation, now we're gonna talk about hair.
4:57 Patrick
Why did we, why did we not have a podcast last week? We were-
5:01 Chad
Uh, two weeks ago, we were, we had our, um, s- management retreat.
5:05 Patrick
Oh, we did.
5:05 Chad
Yeah.
5:05 Patrick
We were planning for the future of Zack. Okay, that's why.
5:08 Chad
Yeah.
5:08 Patrick
Okay. Very nice. All right.
5:10 Chad
So-
5:10 Patrick
Well-
5:10 Chad
Yeah
5:10 Patrick
... let's talk haircuts. One, I noticed that you got a haircut.
5:15 Chad
I did, Monday.
5:16 Patrick
Okay, which doesn't happen very often, I feel like.
5:19 Chad
I actually got a haircut... You, you are correct.
5:21 Patrick
Yeah.
5:21 Chad
I wait way too long.
5:22 Patrick
Uh-huh.
5:22 Chad
I got a haircut much earlier, probably about... I, I waited, like, half as long as I normally do.
5:28 Patrick
Well, so before I met you, you had long hair.
5:32 Chad
When I was in college, I did have long hair, yes.
5:34 Patrick
Not in grad school, though. You'd cut it before we got to grad school.
5:36 Chad
I cut it before I met my wife, yes.
5:38 Patrick
Okay.
5:39 Chad
Which was fortunate, because if she hadn't-
5:40 Patrick
Before you met her or after you met her?
5:42 Chad
I cut it about three months before I met her.
5:44 Patrick
Okay, 'cause she probably would never have dated you with long hair.
5:46 Chad
Oh, never.
5:47 Patrick
Okay.
5:47 Chad
Yeah.
5:48 Patrick
She wasn't into hippies?
5:50 Chad
I mean, we're- I'm talking, like, shoulder-length hair.
5:52 Patrick
Oh, I know.
5:52 Chad
Super thick.
5:53 Patrick
Can, can we go ahead and post the famous picture of, the drum line picture-
5:57 Chad
I will not be posting that picture
5:58 Patrick
... in the show notes?
6:00 Chad
No.
6:00 Patrick
So I used to use this at City Hall all the time when Chad would get on my nerves. I'd go show everybody the picture of Chad on the drum line.
6:07 Chad
That's okay. I would show everyone the picture of you holding that furry little cat.
6:10 Patrick
The cat!
6:11 Chad
At about 10 years old.
6:11 Patrick
That's the one my brother posts on my birthday every year on Facebook to say happy birthday to me. I'm allergic to cats now, which is the irony of that. But, um, yeah, weird. Uh, so Chad got a haircut. It doesn't happen very often, so I do notice when he gets haircuts. Um, it's the... Uh, you know the butler from Mr. Deeds?
6:28 Chad
... Uh, no, never seen it.
6:30 Patrick
You've never seen Mr.-
6:30 Chad
Is that a- that's an Adam Sandler movie, correct?
6:32 Patrick
Yes!
6:33 Chad
Yeah, never seen it.
6:34 Patrick
Okay, so there's the butler in Mr. Deeds, and he's like, he always, like, shows up in the creepiest of, of atmospheres, right? Like, you've seen the pictures of, like, Joe Biden, who sniffs hair, like President Biden sniffing hair?
6:44 Chad
Yes, I have seen those.
6:44 Patrick
Right? Yeah.
6:45 Chad
Yes, I've seen those memes.
6:46 Patrick
So, so, like, my crazy thing is, like, I always notice people's haircuts, like, always. So you remember that in the office, like, like, Shelley would go get her hair done, and I would always, you know, see... I'd be like, "Oh, you dyed your hair," or, "You did this with it," or, you know, like, I don't know. I just... I could always notice hair. It's just the thing I've always been able to notice.
7:02 Chad
Yeah. My wife got her hair done last week.
7:04 Patrick
You didn't notice.
7:05 Chad
I knew she was going to get it-
7:06 Patrick
Mm-hmm
7:07 Chad
... and I still didn't notice. So it was, like, an hour into seeing her that I was like: "Oh, your hair looks great, by the way." So I finally remembered.
7:16 Patrick
Did you put a reminder on your iPhone?
7:19 Chad
No, it just, like, slowly came back to me.
7:21 Patrick
Okay, but I, I do want the podcast to know that that is something Chad would do just to... He, he... You take those extra steps-
7:28 Chad
Oh, yes
7:28 Patrick
... like give yourself a reminder on your iPhone that your wife got a haircut to say that her hair looks good.
7:33 Chad
Yeah, so I do not have the ability to hold a bunch of things in my head at one time.
7:38 Patrick
Is it that, or is it-
7:39 Chad
It's just-
7:39 Patrick
... the Sheldon side of you? I think it's more the Sheldon side of you. It's just things that you don't normally notice.
7:43 Chad
No, man, I'll just, I'll forget. Well, the, uh, that, that, a little bit of that, too.
7:47 Patrick
Okay.
7:47 Chad
But-
7:47 Patrick
It's kind of like when somebody passes gas, you can't smell it.
7:50 Chad
Well, I can't smell anyway.
7:51 Patrick
Yeah, I know. That's makes a good point.
7:53 Chad
So-
7:53 Patrick
Yeah.
7:53 Chad
Yeah.
7:54 Patrick
I used to... It'd be so fun.
7:56 Chad
So how many times did you fart in the truck on the way down to our trip?
7:59 Patrick
On the way to grad school?
8:01 Chad
That, too, yeah.
8:02 Patrick
Man, it was so hard, dude. It was so tough because, you know, I worked, um, uh, I worked down by La Grande Plaza, right? Like, remember-
8:10 Chad
Mm-hmm
8:11 Patrick
... I had the two offices? Technically, three, like, one at City Hall, one at La Grande, and then we had one at what was called the Tindall Building when I was in Fort Worth. And, uh, but I spent most of my time down at La Grande, and man, the food, dude, the food was so zesty. And then you'd have to deal with me in the truck. I'm sorry. So anyways, but sidetrack, do you know the difference between a normal haircut and going to a barber?
8:39 Chad
Uh, I guess just based on the fact that you're asking this question, that I don't.
8:44 Patrick
Uh, okay, so, so there are different licenses, right? There's a cosmetology license, which is, like, you can cut hair, right? And then there's, like, a barber's license, where they can cut hair, and they can do, you know, like, other things, like, you know, noses, ears, shave-
8:57 Chad
Mm-hmm
8:58 Patrick
... like, a, a warm shave. Anyway, so my wife... I take my kids to the local shop, right? Like, the Great Clips or the Sports Clips, okay? And, and to me, a Houston kid, and I hope the Houston people realize this, but you go get a fade in Houston, it's, like, 12 bucks, right? Like, and, and they're doing, like, five guys in an hour. It's just, you know, very common. I think when you live in a humid environment like that, like, you're never gonna have long hair. Like, everybody just goes to get a fade. And, um, well, here, every time you get a fade, it's kind of different, right? So it's been very difficult for me to find a place to go get my hair cut, and so I take my kids there, too, to get their hair cut. And, and sometimes my kids' hair, they have longer, more beautiful, golden lock hair, right? And sometimes they get butchered. And so my wife has been like: "Hey, you know, my, my hairdresser told me you should go to this new barber shop that's in Aledo." Uh, and it's, like, a small mom-and-pop barber shop, okay? Three chairs, super small, very quaint, with, like, legit barbers, and, and I grew up with that. I, I grew up in Katy, and there was a shop called Barreto Barber, and he... Legit, he cut my hair the very first time. So, like, when I was, like, one and a half or two years old, he cut my hair until I graduated high school. I had the same guy who cut my hair. And when I was in high school, before football games, as Chad would say, before I went to sit the bench and watch us win state championships, um, before football games, we would all go to Barreto Barber, and he would cut our hair, and he would do a straight razor shave on our face, right? Which, if you've never had a straight, straight razor save- shave... Have you, on your face, like, with warm?
10:34 Chad
Mm-hmm. I mean, I've done it. I've never had someone do it.
10:37 Patrick
Oh.
10:37 Chad
No, I guess I use a, I use a safety razor.
10:39 Patrick
Yeah, that's not the same.
10:40 Chad
Not like a straight razor.
10:41 Patrick
No, it's like the straight, like, pulls it out.
10:43 Chad
Mm-hmm.
10:43 Patrick
Yeah, you know-
10:44 Chad
Like the Sweeney Todd
10:46 Patrick
... Sweeney Todd, or the thing you get mugged with in a back alley, right? One of those. So anyways, so I went-
10:52 Chad
Speaking of Philadelphia.
10:53 Patrick
Oh, come on!
10:55 Chad
I'm just kidding.
10:55 Patrick
Philadelphia's a safe city. So, um, my dad's from Philly, so I gotta be nice to Philly. Um, my cousin actually has a podcast in Philly. He's, like, really into, like, the club scene there. So, so we're gonna get back to haircuts. So I went to the barber, longest story ever, yesterday, the best haircut I've had in my life, an amazing haircut.
11:18 Chad
It's hard to tell.
11:19 Patrick
But it was-
11:21 Chad
That's like when my dad says he had a good haircut.
11:23 Patrick
How expensive is too expensive for a haircut, a men's haircut? What is, what is the over-under number on that?
11:28 Chad
Including tip or before tip?
11:29 Patrick
Including tip.
11:32 Chad
Um, I cannot get a haircut for less than $22-
11:36 Patrick
Okay, I paid 40-
11:37 Chad
... which already seems expensive.
11:39 Patrick
I paid 46.
11:41 Chad
Yeah.
11:42 Patrick
But-
11:42 Chad
But that's not including tip.
11:44 Patrick
So she cut my hair. Elizabeth was awesome, by the way. She's got a really cool story. I have to get into that later, but she, like, grew up in a really interesting environment. But cut my hair. It was, like, an hour-long experience, and when I got done, she didn't shave my face, but she did straight razor shave on, like, my sideburns, around my ears, and around the back of my neck. I don't know if I'll ever do anything different again. It was, it was, it was-
12:10 Chad
Yeah
12:10 Patrick
... it was a great experience.
12:11 Chad
See, so for me, that would be miserable. Like, however wonderful she is, and however great she does-
12:17 Patrick
'Cause somebody talks to you for an hour?
12:19 Chad
When, when I get a haircut, I want to get in and out. I want to be done as quickly as possible.
12:23 Patrick
No! Don't, don't, don't act like it's you want to get in and out.
12:26 Chad
Mm-hmm.
12:26 Patrick
You don't want to get exhausted because somebody talks to you for an hour.
12:31 Chad
... uh, 100%, yes.
12:33 Patrick
Yeah.
12:33 Chad
Now, I will say that, that I have changed a little bit now that I don't work in an office, because I don't see as many people. So I do find myself... And maybe it's also because I'm just getting older, and that's kind of what you do, is you just, like, talk to people.
12:48 Patrick
Mm-hmm.
12:49 Chad
Um, like, I would always hate going places with my grandpa because he knew everyone, and like, we'd say we'd go to the grocery store to get donuts, we would be there for an hour and a half because he would just find people and talk to them.
12:59 Patrick
Is that why you avoided lunch with me?
13:00 Chad
At the grocery store.
13:02 Patrick
All the time?
13:03 Chad
No-
13:04 Patrick
Lunchtime?
13:04 Chad
... I can talk to people that I know. It's just, like, people-
13:06 Patrick
Okay.
13:06 Chad
I, I'm really, really bad at small talk with people I don't know.
13:09 Patrick
Okay.
13:10 Chad
But I, I find myself talking to, like, cashiers at the gas station that I go, like, down the street.
13:16 Patrick
Okay.
13:16 Chad
If I stop in to get, like, a Topo Chico or something, I'll... Like, I have a- I have my, like, regular morning cashier, and I know her whole life story.
13:25 Patrick
Okay.
13:25 Chad
She knows all my kids, so-
13:27 Patrick
Okay, yeah, that's-
13:28 Chad
I never would've done that, like, 10 years ago.
13:30 Patrick
Yeah, you would never have shared-
13:31 Chad
No
13:31 Patrick
... outside of, you know-
13:32 Chad
Yeah
13:33 Patrick
... your-
13:33 Chad
But I think a combination of COVID and then just working from home has flipped a little bit of a, of a switch for me.
13:40 Patrick
Okay, so that's my... You know, y'all make fun of me for this. Internally, the Zak Team makes fun of me for this, but that's my Chipotle people, right? 'Cause I go to Chipotle, like, three times a week. I know everybody in Chipotle-
13:50 Chad
Mm
13:50 Patrick
... all my employees, so.
13:52 Chad
Yeah. Uh, did I tell you about how, um... So my wife goes to Starbucks at least once a day, sometimes twice, and she gets the exact same thing, and it's, it's not, like, a super crazy drink. It's a grande iced skinny vanilla latte with whipped cream.
14:06 Patrick
Okay.
14:06 Chad
So it's not super crazy.
14:08 Patrick
O- o-
14:08 Chad
A skinny vanilla latte.
14:09 Patrick
Skinny milk? Okay.
14:10 Chad
No, skinny vanilla, yeah.
14:10 Patrick
Okay.
14:11 Chad
Um, but I guess it's unique enough at that store, where all of the people that work there know that that's her drink. So, like, one time, I went to go and get it for her, and when I ordered it at the drive-through, they were like, "Oh, is this for your wife?" Like, I don't, I don't think I've ever said her name, so I'll just, I'll just leave it-
14:29 Patrick
Yeah, yeah
14:29 Chad
... 'cause I know that some of her clients have listened in the past, and I don't wanna-
14:33 Patrick
Yeah
14:33 Chad
... go there. But I was like, "Oh, my gosh, people know her just by her drink order."
14:38 Patrick
That's, uh, yeah, that's, that's wild. My, my funny was the kids and my wife were all off of school. My wife, uh, works in public ed, and they were all off of school one day, and so we went... I was working, and I was like, "All right, hey, let's go to Chipotle." You know, it was my typical Chipotle day. And we walk in, and the Chipotle staff was like, "That's your wife?" And I didn't really know how to take that. So-
15:00 Chad
I think, I think you know how to take it.
15:03 Patrick
Anybody-
15:04 Chad
I think you're the f- you're the first to say that you out-kinked your coverage, uh, obviously.
15:07 Patrick
Oh, 100% out-kinked my coverage. Uh, but, uh, you know, she was 15, and we were in high school, so... Uh, and for some reason, she just thought I was cuddly.
15:15 Chad
Katie wasn't as big then, so the options were more limited.
15:17 Patrick
Katie was 6A back then, or 5A big. We didn't have 6A back then, but come on, Katie's always been a big school. There were three high schools-
15:24 Chad
Yeah
15:24 Patrick
... when I was in high school. Four was added, I think, when I was there.
15:28 Chad
Yeah.
15:28 Patrick
Now there's 12, crazy. But-
15:30 Chad
Yeah.
15:31 Patrick
I-
15:31 Chad
So, so, uh, a couple weeks ago, we, we missed our podcast because we were heading to this, uh, little Zak Tax retreat.
15:38 Patrick
Yep.
15:39 Chad
You know, trying to just get all in the same room and talk about where we wanna head this year. Um, we had talked about actually, just kinda joked about, like, re- just recording on the phone, like, in the car on the way down there. But it turns out that that day was kind of a crazy day-
15:56 Patrick
Oh, it was nuts
15:56 Chad
... because sales tax data came out, and there was massive audit corrections across the state. And I think you wanted to just touch on that a little bit.
16:06 Patrick
I mean, first off, you and I trying to get away, 'cause really it was just, it was, it was you and I trying to get away so that we could have a conversation. The car ride was probably the most beneficial both, both directions for a little while. But we've been trying to do that for years, to try to, you know, just kinda get away and coordinate and try to figure out, "Okay, hey, let's, let's, like, have a plan." Um-
16:26 Chad
Remember the last time we did it, y'all went to Scottsdale, and then everybody got COVID.
16:30 Patrick
That's true, on the way back.
16:30 Chad
And for some reason, we, like, at the last minute, we had to stop. I think one of our kids got sick.
16:34 Patrick
One of your kids got sick, yeah.
16:35 Chad
Yeah.
16:35 Patrick
And, and I don't, I don't think your... Like, now all y'all's family members live up in North Texas, it's a little easier for you, but back then, I don't think everybody did, right?
16:44 Chad
Yeah. Also, I think my wife was pregnant.
16:46 Patrick
Yeah, I think that's also the case.
16:48 Chad
So-
16:48 Patrick
Yeah, so
16:48 Chad
... it worked out well that we didn't go.
16:50 Patrick
It's a good thing you've stopped having kids now.
16:52 Chad
Yeah, no kidding.
16:53 Patrick
What about dogs? You still have dogs?
16:55 Chad
Still have... No, no, no more dogs.
16:57 Patrick
No more dogs, okay. Uh, Chad is over the legal limit for the amount of dogs you can have in most cities, uh, but, you know, that's okay.
17:03 Chad
Good thing I don't live in the city.
17:04 Patrick
That's true.
17:05 Chad
Actually, it's not a good thing. I w- I wish I did, but...
17:08 Patrick
It's, it's hard for you. It's very difficult. Um, so yeah, so we're, we're getting on the road. All of a sudden, I, I... Who reached out to us first? Was it a city, or was it Allison? I think maybe Allison was the one who caught the data first and was like, "Hey, there's something goofy here."
17:24 Chad
Yeah, I think so.
17:25 Patrick
And then, I mean, at, at that point, it's just like everybody started reaching out as the data hit. Uh, and, and, you know, for those that don't look in the sales tax world, sales tax data hits in Texas, uh, usually on a Wednesday, right? So Wednesday morning, uh, and it's usually the first full week Wednesday of the month. And, um, sales tax hit, they just kind of post it to a website, and the data doesn't come for another week or so, and so it got posted. There was a huge audit adjustment. We can't tell you exactly who the audit adjustment was, but it was, you know, across the state, multiple cities, same taxpayer, uh, and, you know, in the energy sector. We could say that.
18:07 Chad
I think that's fair.
18:08 Patrick
Okay. So, uh, so we'll say in the energy sector, uh, there was a player that had an audit adjustment. Uh, we have asked lots of questions, uh, to the Comptroller's office. They have been fantastic to work with and continue to be fantastic to work with, and they are still trying to figure it out themselves. Uh, one of the issues that we have in Texas right now, it's something that we really need to address in the legislative session and have some conversations on-... is there is a limit when there's an audit done. So when a state initiates an audit or a city has the state initiate an audit for a taxpayer that should be paying them or is paying them in-incorrectly, one or the other, um, there's a limit on that rollback. I believe that limit's four years, and they can't go any further than that. But there's kind of a loophole in the statute on that, and in the rules, that allows for lawsuits that are filed to roll back even further. And so this audit adjustment, um, goes back- what is the actual term, Chad? It was-
19:04 Chad
Um, it was 2010 to 2013.
19:06 Patrick
Okay, so we're talking about money that was allocated-
19:08 Chad
14-year-old, yeah. 14 years ago.
19:11 Patrick
14 years ago, and is now impacting some cities' budgets, uh-
19:15 Chad
Significantly
19:16 Patrick
... So I mean, by one city's accounting, it's 10% of their entire general fund budget.
19:20 Chad
Yeah, there were several cities that literally got no allocations this month.
19:24 Patrick
Yeah, and that, they'll probably not have part of an allocation next month, too, to continue-
19:28 Chad
Mm-hmm
19:28 Patrick
... to cover it, right? So I wanna say this first. I wanna, you know, before we get into what we know at this point-
19:35 Chad
But j- just to be clear, this was, this was a reallocation.
19:42 Patrick
Correct.
19:44 Chad
Right.
19:44 Patrick
We, we can't see it all, but we believe it's a full-
19:46 Chad
Yes
19:46 Patrick
... reallocation.
19:47 Chad
We can't see every city, but for cities that we have seen, it's the same taxpayer, negative for some, positive for others.
19:54 Patrick
And we don't know why. Right. And it doesn't really make sense to us either, so we're trying to work through that as well. Um, but I wanna say a couple of things before we get into some nitty-gritties on this. One, I wanna say, if you were a city that was negatively impacted by this allocation and you've never gone through this before, the comptroller does have a program where you can, uh, get that money back, and then they will take it out over a payment period, uh, somewhere between usually 36 and 48 months. You can negotiate for length. Uh-
20:26 Chad
Especially if it's something that's this large.
20:28 Patrick
Yes. They'll offer you 12 months. You can always get more than 12. That's kinda like their general offer on the table. We've dealt with this numerous times with numerous clients, and it's just a, it's a simple phone call, and it's a simple little one-page agreement, uh, that you sign with the Comptroller's Office. It just says, "We're gonna take this out over the next 48 months instead of taking it out over, uh, the single month." So you can get it spread over multiple fiscal years. Um, you know, obviously, for those cities that have huge impacts of, like, 10% or more, it's, it's, it's just a, it's an enormous hit, right? Um, but yeah, I wanna get that out there first because I think it's extremely important to say, "Hey, don't freak out." If it hits you hard, we totally understand. Um, we still are skeptical at this point. I, I, I wanna say that very clearly. I'm not saying that the impact is not actually going to occur or it's not real, I'm just saying that we have our antennas up to... It's just doesn't seem like this was supposed to happen like it happened. Um, and we haven't got an explanation out of the Comptroller's office, and to be fair, the Comptroller's office is not really squared away internally, um, what has happened either. One side of the Comptroller's office is the one who programmed the allocation that way, but that was not actually allocations. Um, you think we can go any deeper than that or kinda keep it there?
21:41 Chad
No, actually, I was probably gonna even cut short before that point, but yeah-
21:46 Patrick
Okay
21:46 Chad
... 'cause there are a lot of question marks-
21:48 Patrick
And, and I just-
21:49 Chad
Trying to answer
21:50 Patrick
... I, I wanna reiterate, right? Now, they get paid 2% of allocations, so they, they should be good at what they do. That's a lot of money. Um, but they're very good to work with.
22:02 Chad
Yeah.
22:03 Patrick
Okay? So-
22:03 Chad
It is a lot of money, by the way.
22:04 Patrick
It is a lot of money, and there's a lot of moving parts. There's policy section, there's tax audit section, there's allocations. These are all different large-scale departments within the same, um, you know, Comptroller's office, right? And they all have to work together, and we work with all different aspects of them, and there's good people there, and they're doing hard work. And so, you know, our biggest criticism of this process is these audits should have been notified prior to them being removed from a payment. That's the biggest criticism. The side of the Comptroller's office that we would normally deal with, that would send out that letter, which would be the allocation side, was unaware of the audit adjustments, as, as far as we can tell at this point. We are still asking questions. They are still responding to us on a daily basis, telling us that they're still working through some of those questions, and when we know more, we will share more. So I wanted to put that out there. You got anything else there before I jump-
23:02 Chad
No
23:02 Patrick
... into the kinda problem with what we have here and what we see on our data side? So I wanna-
23:09 Chad
Yeah, go for it.
23:10 Patrick
I wanna talk a little bit about the industry that's kinda popped up, and we don't know if this is the case on this audit adjustment, but we've seen it on other audit adjustments. But there's been an industry that's kinda popped up that buys this possible tax reallocation or possible, um, tax reduction. So it, this happens a lot in the oil and gas business. So we have a lot of our cities in the Houston area, cities in East Texas, that are very, uh, oil and gas dependent. We see this a lot. Now, they're typically notified when it happens. So, like, when a lawsuit gets filed, they get notified that a lawsuit was filed, and, you know, just be aware that this money may be, you know, it, it may be, it may get called back. There's nothing, like, statutory though, that requires the Comptroller's office to do that. We think there probably ought to be something there. I, I do personally. Chad, we've kinda talked about that. I think you do, too, but-
23:59 Chad
So to notify them?
24:00 Patrick
Yeah, so when, when-
24:01 Chad
Yes
24:02 Patrick
... when the Comptroller's office gets sued-
24:03 Chad
It's, it's quite simple to just-
24:04 Patrick
For an allocation
24:04 Chad
... send a letter or an email.
24:05 Patrick
Yeah, anybody who's impacted should be notified there's been a lawsuit filed. The problem is, is that some of these-
24:10 Chad
I feel like there should probably also be some kind of website where you can see all of the pending lawsuits-
24:14 Patrick
So-
24:14 Chad
... because imagine how many people on your staff from 2010 are still there.
24:21 Patrick
And that's where the problem comes in, though, because a lot of these lawsuits are, uh, private. They're not public. They're not publicly filed. They go through a very private process because it's, um, because it's sales tax, individual business sales tax data, right? And so they're able to keep that.... private. I think we should at least notify, just like we have a 380 agreement section on the comptroller's website that says, "A 380 agreement with this company is here," right? We should at least have something that says, "We have pending lawsuits with these taxpayers who are suing to get their taxes back." Right? That's it. We don't have to give the tax amount-
24:55 Chad
Yeah
24:55 Patrick
... but we need to notify what jurisdictions that they're suing and, and who, because those jurisdictions are not aware. They're not a part of the lawsuit, 'cause the comptroller is a state- it's- sales tax goes at the state level. There's no, there's no local jurisdiction on, on sales tax. So I think it would be good to notify there. But there's a whole industry that we really need to talk about. It's kind of an underbelly, that they go in, especially in the oil and gas companies, and they will find that the oil and gas companies paid sales tax that they shouldn't have paid. And they'll buy that liability from them, right? So they'll go in there and they'll say, "Hey, you paid a million dollars in sales tax, and you really shouldn't have. We'll pay you 20 cents on the dollar. So we'll pay you $200,000 if you let us go sue to get this back for you." So you kind of assign all that over. Um, and so sometimes those audit payments are going, uh, to a different company than what the audit payments came in as, right? Um, so that's kinda there, too. So there's a whole industry that's kinda set up to, to do that, that are law firms, hedge fund-backed type stuff, that get into that as well. And we're seeing more and more of that. And I think when it was one-off, and we only saw maybe one or two of these occasionally a year, and it didn't really have an impact, it wasn't that big a deal, but it's just becoming more commonplace. And so, think we're gonna have to have this conversation. It's just like property tax, though. It's such a complicated issue, trying to find a state legislature that a- a state legislator that actually understands the issue is super hard, right? Um, and so it's, it's gonna have to be comptroller's office-led. They're gonna have to go in there and say... And I think this could be that one adjustment where we're like, "Okay, you know, this is such a sizable adjustment. We don't really know why it happened yet, but it's such a sizable adjustment impacting so many people that we need to go ahead and, you know, create some ground rules or some barriers here to, to keep this from happening in the future." Thoughts?
26:51 Chad
I was trying to, as you were talking about that, I was trying to think whether the property tax side or the sales tax side is less understood in the legislature. And at first, my immediate thought was, like, absolutely, property tax is far less understood.
27:07 Patrick
Mm.
27:08 Chad
But then I remembered some of the hearings that we had-
27:11 Patrick
Sourcing?
27:12 Chad
... uh, regarding the sourcing and the nexus.
27:14 Patrick
Oh, yeah.
27:14 Chad
And, and it made me question whether or not that initial, um, that initial judgment was wrong.
27:20 Patrick
That-
27:20 Chad
I think it's probably still, still correct, but yeah, the, like, it's a lot closer than I initially was thinking about.
27:25 Patrick
And I'm not being critical of this, the legislators-
27:28 Chad
It's complex
27:28 Patrick
... super complex.
27:29 Chad
They have a lot of issues that they're trying to deal with.
27:31 Patrick
Yeah.
27:31 Chad
It's just one of many things.
27:33 Patrick
Yeah. It's, it's a, it's a very difficult thing to, to try to, to... It's just very, it's, it's very difficult to understand, especially when you get into the rulemaking side. Not just the legislative side, but the rulemaking side. 'Cause you have the statute that says what sales tax should, should be charged on and how it should be charged, and things like that. And then you have a whole separate rulemaking authority that the comptroller's office has that just has years and years of historical rulemaking in it, and it's layer upon layer. And so, um, you know, and you have industries that are dependent on that taxation system to be stable. Uh, so yeah, it's, it's super complicated. I just remember when we went through the sourcing conversation, we always thought that, you know, in a utopian world, this would be perfect. Yeah, of course, you would want to source sales tax to its point of destination. Like, that, that would be the easiest thing in the world to do, but that's not how the economy in Texas has grown over the last 40, 50 years. So it's- you know, you're not really set up that way to be able to provide services in a manner that would be, that would work in a pure destination format. So I don't know. Little by little, it seems like we're-
28:40 Chad
Well, that's why we kinda came up with the change of possession verbiage.
28:43 Patrick
Yeah.
28:44 Chad
Right? 'Cause it's kind of shows how the two different sides of the coin aren't that dissimilar. Like, if we look at origin sourcing and destination sourcing, we think, "Oh, these are, like, vastly different mechanisms for determining nexus," but really they're not.
29:00 Patrick
Yeah, you know, like, sales operations and business operations and things like that, a lot of that, uh, still survived some of the rule change that occurred, and so there's, there's still just, like, this... There's still a little bit of a goofy hybrid nature to, uh, to it.
29:15 Chad
Yeah.
29:16 Patrick
But-
29:16 Chad
And then, like, if you only have one l- physical lo- like, one office or one location, you can source all your sales tax there.
29:22 Patrick
Yes, and correct. So now that, now that... So, like, you know, lawnmowing companies-
29:26 Chad
Like landscapers
29:27 Patrick
... landscapers, yeah.
29:28 Chad
Yeah.
29:28 Patrick
Um, now that we're in California, though, I'm curious, um, can we say this out loud? Texas d- actually does it better.
29:37 Chad
I was gonna say, for how complicated things are and how crazy things get sometimes, you guys have it, you have it better-
29:45 Patrick
Yeah, 100%
29:46 Chad
... it do in California. It is a very just needlessly complicated system, and we're trying to kind of figure out how to, how to look at both Texas and California in a sort of more abstract and consistent way, and just trying to, like, fit that square peg in a round hole has been, has been interesting.
30:11 Patrick
Now, um, you know in Texas how we had the argument about, like, uh, building codes and how trades were pushing s- building codes a certain way to make things more expensive? Like, this is-
30:19 Chad
Sure
30:19 Patrick
... it became a whole thing here. The conspiracy theorist in me is, is, is really starting to contemplate that, uh, California's really been driven by the consultant side on some of the rulemaking. The more complicated you make it, the more dependent you have to be on a consultant. And that's the-
30:36 Chad
Yeah
30:36 Patrick
... city manager in me talking, obviously, not the consultant. So, but it seems like there are just a couple of things that are goofy-... in the way that they do it, and it's not really making communities any more money or any less money, it's just overly complicated. So-
30:52 Chad
Yeah.
30:52 Patrick
I may be wrong on that, but I, I think-
30:55 Chad
It is certainly overly complicated.
30:57 Patrick
It's, it's very overly complicated, and it's gonna, it's gonna take me years to understand it. I mean, there's, there's no doubt it's gonna take me years to understand it. So are you ready to move on to downtowns?
31:06 Chad
Yeah. So we're, uh... We don't say- we won't say who this was, but we were heading to a city in Texas for this retreat.
31:12 Patrick
Yep.
31:13 Chad
Coincidentally, that city has reached out to, uh, to you, Patrick, and asked you a question that we thought might spur a little bit interesting conversation.
31:20 Patrick
Yeah, basically, I got asked the question... You know, we don't- uh, I was asked the question: Do we, anywhere in the software, compare geographic regions from other cities? Uh, it's an interesting question. Sounds like a future thing to discuss in ZactX. Uh, but we don't-
31:34 Chad
Sounds like a future opt-in feature.
31:36 Patrick
Opt-in feature, yeah, 100%, right. Um, and so I think, uh, the answer to the question obviously is no, we don't, because it's confidential data and we can't share it across cities. But when you look at things from, um, you know, obviously from a perspective of-
31:51 Chad
When you aggregate them enough-
31:52 Patrick
When you aggregate them enough-
31:53 Chad
... you can... Yes
31:53 Patrick
- you can start to look at it, and you can start to give everybody an idea. And I think, you know, this individual city was looking at, "Hey, we have a historic downtown, and I just kinda wanna know how everybody else's historic downtowns are performing," right? That's kinda what we're looking at. So, um, I was like: Yeah, I, I'll nerd out with you and go look at, you know, a couple of communities that I would consider to be, you know, historic. So, you know, going through and looking at historic downtowns, uh, which I- we're gonna talk a little bit about kind of the historic downtowns, and then we're gonna talk a little bit about, like, what I would consider to be, like, your, you know, may- you know, a little, little more like business downtowns.
32:31 Chad
Okay. Like a CBD?
32:33 Patrick
Yeah, like a CBD. Yeah.
32:34 Chad
Okay, in, in this particular example, we're talking about smaller town downtowns, right? Not like downtown Austin.
32:41 Patrick
That's correct.
32:42 Chad
Yeah.
32:42 Patrick
In this particular example, we're talking about smaller downtowns. Um, and from what I can find, the four or five that I've looked at so far, um-
32:49 Chad
Oh, you've, you've got data?
32:51 Patrick
I've got data.
32:52 Chad
Okay.
32:52 Patrick
Yeah.
32:53 Chad
I didn't realize you were doing some research.
32:55 Patrick
Well, I, I actually told the city that I would reach back out to them and give them a synopsis, so-
33:00 Chad
Are you going to just make them listen to the podcast?
33:03 Patrick
No, I'm not gonna make them listen to the podcast.
33:04 Chad
Okay.
33:04 Patrick
But since I was doing the work, I thought, you know, why, why not, you know, why not throw this into the podcast, right, and have that conversation? So of those communities that I looked at, um, you know, looking at those kind of historic downtowns that they've got, uh, overall, they've actually performed a, a little, a little better than I expected. Uh, so you know, I... There's been some, you know, kind of interesting growth from a standpoint of those downtown areas. They've had kind of the same negative months, which has been interesting. Uh, so many of those downtown areas have seen, uh, since the start of the fiscal year, have seen two down negative months, uh, verse, uh, those that are years. And they are- it looks like the ones that I would consider to be more touristy towns, towns that are like, you know, VRBO, Airbnb, like, weekend getaways, seem to, to have, uh, a little more of a, a detrimental impact in the negative side. Whereas those downtowns that are historic downtowns outside of major metropolitan areas, uh, which would be more of like a Saturday night restaurant getaway-type spot, uh, are- tend to be okay, 4% to 5% up verse, you know, 2% to 10% down. Um, so that's, that's been interesting to me. So, you know, those things that-
34:23 Chad
How have these... How have these downtowns compared to their, like, power centers?
34:29 Patrick
You know, I didn't look at that. I- that's, uh, that's interesting. So is, is the downtown, you know, historic core, how's that performing against the power centers?
34:38 Chad
Yeah, like, I have no idea which cities you looked at, but the one that I'm thinking of in my head is Weatherford, 'cause I'm familiar with it.
34:47 Patrick
Okay.
34:47 Chad
They've got their historic downtown up on 180 and 51.
34:51 Patrick
Mm-hmm.
34:52 Chad
And then about two miles south, right on 20, is their, like, major power center. There's, like, a Walmart. There's a Lowe's, Target, right? All of the, like, big boxes on the highway. Um, if you could think of those two, like, distinct regions in, in cities of probably that size, maybe more often than not, sort of on the periphery of a major urbanized area.
35:17 Patrick
I think with those towns, I just looked at two of them real quick. Um, and I did not look at Weatherford since you said it out loud-
35:23 Chad
Okay.
35:23 Patrick
... just wanna point that out. Um, I think with those, those two towns, uh, most power centers are down statewide, right? Most general retail sales are down, and that's what you're gonna find in your power centers. Grocery is up in most areas, right? General retail is down. And I think, you know, you could look at the market, stock market, right? You can look at the guidance being given from Best Buy, Kohl's-
35:48 Chad
Walmart, Target. Yeah
35:49 Patrick
... Walmart, Target, all that. All their guidance right now is negative, right? So I don't think that's gonna shock anybody that we're seeing, you know, somewhat stagnant and negative numbers. Um, whereas, no, I re- I really would say from a downtown standpoint, it seems to me that, like, downtowns that are within a spitting distance of a metropolitan area, within 30 minutes or so of, of a major, uh, employment center, s- seem to be doing, uh, well. So, and downtowns that are a little further out or "touristy," quote, unquote, in a state, which there are lots of in Texas, uh, it's one of the best parts about the state of Texas in my opinion, you can always like, you know, grab a VRBO and go have yourself a little, you know, romantic retreat on the weekend, um, and lots of small towns. Uh, so DFW, you know, obviously is not super far from, you know, either going down towards the lakes in South Texas or going to... I had to get my South Texas comment in there. Or head, you know, headed to the Hill Country, whichever way you wanna go. Um, they seem to be-... stutter in just a little bit more. To conclude on this, downtowns are super finicky, right? Every downtown has, like, its own living, breathing culture, uh, that's adjusted to it. I- so it's very difficult to compare downtowns, right? Like, it's really, really hard to look at it. Um, but overall, the downtown areas actually seem more stable than your general retail power centers.
37:21 Chad
Right now.
37:21 Patrick
I think that's the best comparison to look at right now. Yeah.
37:23 Chad
Yeah.
37:24 Patrick
So Main Street is doing better than Wall Street.
37:28 Chad
Okay.
37:28 Patrick
There you go.
37:30 Chad
So when you mentioned this topic, Patrick, um, one thing I thought might be worth talking about is how imp- important that downtown is.
37:38 Patrick
Uh-huh.
37:38 Chad
Like, I would bet if you looked at just nominal revenue, most of those smaller downtowns are not generating as much as their power centers, right? They, they generate a lot of revenue. They take up a lot of space, but they generate a, a lot of revenue. But the one thing that I always think about, like, as I'm driving across the state, is every place looks the same, right? Like, our economic development efforts are so focused on bringing in the exact same, uh, businesses in the exact same format, and everything just looks the same.
38:14 Patrick
Yeah.
38:14 Chad
The downtown is the differentiator.
38:17 Patrick
I-
38:17 Chad
Like, okay, so, you know, maybe you feel like you need to have... maybe you need to have that power center with, you know, either whether it's a Walmart, or Target, or a Low- Lowe's or Home Depot, or, you know, we're gonna have to have these sort of secondary, uh, uh, stores that follow our anchors. We have to have these restaurants. You know, we're gonna get our Chili's and our Pluckers, and whatever else. Everyone has those. It's so boring.
38:37 Patrick
So should we-
38:38 Chad
And your downtown is like your hidden gem of uniqueness and what your city is, and we just neglect it.
38:45 Patrick
I, I mean, man, I just, I, I have to say this and give a huge shout-out. Granbury, Texas, has done an absolute tremendous job with their downtown. Um, they have fine dining, Two Fish Tacos. They have live music. They have a theater. I mean, it is tremendous what has gone on in, in Granbury. It, it is, it is a gem of a city. I jokingly call it the place where all city managers go to retire, 'cause- ... I, I feel like there are- I run into a retired city manager in Granbury all the time. But, um, it is such a sense of place. But in today's world, in Texas, you couldn't do that. Like, Granbury, when they built downtown, required everything to have Granbury stone on it, which is a very specific white chalk-type stone.
39:35 Chad
That's fine.
39:36 Patrick
Right?
39:36 Chad
But that's j- that's sort of, uh... I mean, I get how that affects the public realm, but it is- it's just a piece of the puzzle that makes that place feel the way that it does.
39:49 Patrick
Right.
39:50 Chad
Right? It doesn't ha- like, it could be brick, and it would still have that unique feel of a downtown versus a s- a cinder block or a tilt-wall, 200,000-square foot, you know, box store in a power center.
40:05 Patrick
The river that they have adjacent to it, the city hall complex that they built, I mean, the generations of, the generations of leadership-
40:12 Chad
That park on the backside of the city hall is so cool when you walk in.
40:15 Patrick
Dude, it's incredible. Uh, but the generations of leadership that it takes to build what they built there is just... it's wild. And they have power centers that are out-
40:26 Chad
Of course they do
40:26 Patrick
... you know, off the 377 and, and some other areas, if you know that market well. They have a lot going on, but it is incredible. They, they don't- I mean, from an industry standpoint, right, they have some industry that's been driven by people who've moved there because of the environment that has been built, especially Covid. A lot of people moved there in, in the Covid side 'cause it's just such a dynamic little city. Their population is not huge.
40:53 Chad
It's not. But let me ask you a question. When you think of Granbury, do you think of the downtown, or do you think of the power center?
41:01 Patrick
I think of downtown.
41:02 Chad
Now, think of another random city in your head. Do you think of the unique things, or does... Like, when you picture it, are you picturing the same stuff that is everywhere else?
41:14 Patrick
Well, so I... You know, that's a really good question. Uh, so I went to Crowley today to, uh, they have one of their staff members who's leaving, and so, uh, who's been a good friend of ours, uh, Jack Thompson. Congratulations on getting the city manager job in La Grange. And so I was in La Grange today, or sorry, Crowley.
41:30 Chad
Crowley.
41:30 Patrick
I was in Crowley today, and, um, you know, I think 10 years ago, and a lot of people probably still think this, if you think of Crowley, Texas, all you think about is just urban sprawl, right? Like, it's just, it is what it is. Man, their downtown redevelopment that they worked really hard on, I mean, you, you've, you and I have known Robert, the city manager there, for a long time. I mean, he's basically spent a, a generation at this point trying to bring that city to where it's at now. Man, their downtown development is awesome. Like, the plaza that they built, um, you know, the things that they had to do, and you knew they took a ton of heat trying to build all that, to give Crowley a sense of place, to not just be a postage stamp on the way to work, but to actually be a community on its own. Um, you know, they got it started. It's not done by any means, but they got it started. They have a walkable downtown space.
42:21 Chad
Well, it's a city that's never done.
42:23 Patrick
Yeah, so I don't-
42:26 Chad
That, that... Hold on. That is such a wild thing that you just said.
42:30 Patrick
What's that?
42:32 Chad
It's not done.
42:33 Patrick
Yeah.
42:34 Chad
Do you... I, I, I wanna a- analyze the psychology of that statement.
42:38 Patrick
Okay, go for it.
42:39 Chad
Okay. Do we ever think of these things as done?
42:43 Patrick
No.
42:45 Chad
Do we really? Maybe we do.
42:48 Patrick
Sad. I, I think that's a sad approach.
42:51 Chad
Oh, I maybe, I agree, but like, "Okay, we're built out. We've got our, we got our stuff here. We're done."... like, we're done with this development. What does it mean to be done with the development?
43:00 Patrick
I mean-
43:01 Chad
And, and what is the tra- trajectory of a development if you build it and you're done with it? Can it go, uh, can it get better? Or can it- is it gonna stay the same, or is it gonna get worse?
43:11 Patrick
Well, I think it could stay the same. Uh, look, I can- I think complacency is always, is always, uh, less, right? So stay the same to me is always loss. So, um-
43:23 Chad
Now, I, I wanna clarify, no one at Crowley said that they- that they're done, right? That was just you-
43:26 Patrick
No, in fact, it-
43:27 Chad
... that was just a throwaway line that you said.
43:29 Patrick
That was a throwaway line.
43:29 Chad
I'm just digging into the- into the throwaway line here.
43:31 Patrick
In, in fact, Robert, when he was talking about the work that they had done together, he was talking about Jack specifically and the work that they've done together, and it's pretty special what they've done. Um, and they've got another great ACM, DCM over there, Laurie, who's taking over as city manager when, when Robert retires here in a little bit. But, um, Robert made the comment that, "There were, there were people before me, and there will be people after me, and it's the responsibility of those that come after all of us, and, uh, to continue that, to, to keep moving in that direction," right? Um, and I think that's the amazing thing about Granbury is that it's like it's never stopped.
44:07 Chad
Mm-hmm.
44:07 Patrick
I mean, y- they, you know, they've got an old historic movie theater down there. They've got an old, um, you know, Granbury Live, which is a, you know, almost like a little mini opry, right? I mean, you get to see some pretty cool things in that town.
44:20 Chad
Yeah.
44:20 Patrick
And, and it's just continued to get improved, uh, from that standpoint.
44:26 Chad
Uh, uh, and it's-
44:26 Patrick
And it's not vehicle-centric. That's the crazy thing about their downtown. They have a parking area around the square, but really that's the secondary-
44:35 Chad
Once you get there, you can walk from place to place.
44:37 Patrick
Yeah. Once you get there, it's very, it's very walkable. So it's kind of... It's, you know, whereas, uh, I would say Weatherford, which is right down the road, and Weatherford's done a tremendous job with their downtown, and they continue to throw, uh, what I would consider pocket projects. And they're- so instead of going and spending $30 million and trying to do some crazy redevelopment project, Weatherford's, you know, doing small projects here and there and done a really good job with it, and allowed some of the residential houses right off of downtown to be converted to commercial.
45:03 Chad
Yeah. It's the Jane Jacobs approach.
45:06 Patrick
Yeah, and it's, it's, it's worked.
45:08 Chad
Yeah.
45:08 Patrick
And, and they're doing, they're doing a really good job on it. Um, funny enough, I think internally, um, or politically, I think, would be the better... Not internally, but politically, I think they still focus on the big wins out on the interstate, right? And I think the point you're trying to make, and it's a good point, is what do you actually recognize when you talk about Weatherford, Texas?
45:27 Chad
Right.
45:27 Patrick
You recognize-
45:27 Chad
If you were to talk about a city like Weatherford, would you want to think about the power center on 20, or would you want to think about the downtown? Like, if you worked for the city, if you live in the city-
45:35 Patrick
Right
45:35 Chad
... what would you want people from outside the city to picture in their head when they hear the name?
45:41 Patrick
Which you can... So the, the square, right, and the courthouse. The courthouse is, is one of the prettiest courthouses in Texas. It's gorgeous, right?
45:51 Chad
It's much better than the, like, castle with turrets that we saw the other day.
45:55 Patrick
Well, let's not call out a county courthouse.
45:57 Chad
That was wild.
45:58 Patrick
That wasn't very-
45:58 Chad
I know. I didn't say who it was, but it was wild, though.
46:01 Patrick
So-
46:01 Chad
It's like medieval England drive-thru.
46:03 Patrick
Um, so so- somebody is gonna send us an email and be like, "I figured out where you went."
46:06 Chad
"That's my courthouse!"
46:07 Patrick
Yeah. They're gonna be like, "I tracked all the different things you talked about, and we figured out where you went." But, I mean, you know, honest- honestly, there's truth on that. Um, like, you can't... It's, it's hard to safely walk to the courthouse because of the way the traffic circle in Weatherford works, right?
46:21 Chad
Yeah. Thanks, TxDOT.
46:22 Patrick
Yeah. So, um, and, and those are... That's one of those things about, you know, we're just- we were very car-centric when... You know, that was even, that was, like, a '90s project, right? That wasn't even, like, an '80s-style project. That was, like, 1990s, early 2000s, and, you know, like, the walls, the, the famous walls that get knocked over on the square were, were installed back in the early 2000s, and so they've done some stuff there. But overall, they've actually made some progress. They've tightened up streets, they've changed the way the parking lots work, and it's slowed traffic down, even though it's still a state highway coming through the middle of it. Um, and they've done it without having to reroute an entire state highway, which was always kind of the thought, that they would have to do that to revitalize downtown, and they've been able to revitalize downtown with the state highway still going through it, which is impressive. It does still take a little too much of a car to get around there, right? If you wanna go from one side of the square to the other, I'm not sure playing Frogger across the highway is the way to do it. But, um, you know, but they've, they've been able to kinda create these, like, mini economies on each segment of the square. So one segment has, like, attorneys and title companies and things like that, like professional services, and then one side of the square has, like, restaurants and-
47:29 Chad
Has my cigar shop.
47:30 Patrick
... That's your cigar shop, yes.
47:32 Chad
Yeah.
47:32 Patrick
Uh, and, you know, some other things. And so they've kinda created, like, these little pods, and they've done pretty well with that, and they've brought a lot of employment to that downtown area as well. It's been pretty impressive, uh, especially because they started with something that was very difficult. Kinda like Crowley, started with something that was just a drive-through. Um, and so, um... You know, but I, I think places like a Fredericksburg, right, or a, uh, you know, a Granbury, uh, or a Georgetown, or some of these other folks, like, they start with something that is much more dynamic and much more historical and, and move into that. Another one that we don't really talk about as an episo- or not an episode of, but, uh, Nacogdoches.
48:13 Chad
Nacogdoches.
48:13 Patrick
Yeah, Nacogdoches is a, is another cool little downtown. Uh, and, you know, the question is, do you have to have... What do you have to do as a city manager to be able to build things like that? Like, do you have to be-
48:26 Chad
You don't have to, you have- you don't have to do anything. We used to build things like that. All those places are from 120 years ago.
48:33 Patrick
Yeah, but to keep it going, like-
48:35 Chad
You have to not divert all of your resources elsewhere.
48:40 Patrick
Fair. But don't you need to continue-
48:42 Chad
Like, that's how you have to start it
48:42 Patrick
... to get private inve- don't you continue have to get private investment in those areas, though?
48:47 Chad
You do, but when-
48:48 Patrick
So don't you have to be-
48:49 Chad
Your attention is-
48:50 Patrick
... an evangelical downtown?
48:51 Chad
Oh, yes, absol- I mean, y- you're the salesperson here.
48:54 Patrick
Yeah.
48:55 Chad
Right?
48:56 Patrick
Correct.
48:57 Chad
... so I think you know quite well how, how much you have to evangelize it. You have to find the things that make it special, and then highlight those things, and make it seem like it's way better than it is so that you can attract investment and actually make it realize its potential.
49:13 Patrick
So-
49:13 Chad
It's really hard to do that if all of your attention is focused on the highway.
49:17 Patrick
I would agree. I would agree with that. Uh-
49:19 Chad
And focus on a development pattern that we- not to, like, harp again on the power centers, 'cause there's a, there's a place for them, and there's obviously a market for them, but when we build them, we're done with them.
49:33 Patrick
But do you think remote-
49:33 Chad
Like, what a, what a boring way to, like, run a city is to build a bunch of stuff that we just kind of say, "All right, we're done with this. Let's move on to the next one." Like, we should be looking for options in places where we can continually improve-
49:47 Patrick
But-
49:47 Chad
... and a, and a type of place that can continually get better.
49:52 Patrick
But do you think remote sales actually creates a better niche for downtowns?
49:57 Chad
For downtowns? Absolutely.
49:58 Patrick
Yeah, me too. Like, I, I, I think, I think Main Street would-
50:03 Chad
You, you can, you will be able-
50:05 Patrick
claim that Wall Street took advantage of them in that. Like, the closing of the bookstore, right? Like, the Amazon-
50:08 Chad
Mm-hmm
50:08 Patrick
... taking over the Barnes & Nobles, right? I think they would claim that's the case.
50:11 Chad
You will be able to put your Walmarts, and your Targets, and your Home Depots, and your Lowe's, you'll be able to put them way out in the middle of nowhere because they're gonna be mostly just, like, delivery traffic.
50:24 Patrick
Yeah.
50:25 Chad
We're not gonna actually go to those stores. Like, they're gonna build concepts that have smaller footprints, because more and more of the shopping that occurs there is gonna happen online.
50:36 Patrick
Well, it's a lifestyle center, right? Like, your downtown should be the lifestyle center.
50:41 Chad
Yeah.
50:41 Patrick
Like, it should be, it should be-
50:42 Chad
The, the beauty of downtowns as a lifestyle center versus the sort of artificial lifestyle centers that we try to create, is that the, the uniqueness and the, the incremental growth of those downtowns give it an actual sense of place, and not just, like, this sort of artificial facade that we, we built this huge lifestyle center-
51:02 Patrick
Yeah
51:02 Chad
... now you should come here and, and enjoy it.
51:06 Patrick
It's-
51:06 Chad
I'm thinking of a handful of them that I don't... I won't mention, but-
51:09 Patrick
Yeah, I, I, you know... And, and some of those are gonna be, you know, sprawl communities that never had downtowns, right? They just became cities in the middle of nowhere over time, and so they're gonna have to create some type of-
51:23 Chad
True, but Hudson Oaks never had, like, a downtown, but the big plan that we-
51:29 Patrick
Right
51:29 Chad
... put together was to essentially create one.
51:31 Patrick
And I wouldn't say that... I don't think that plan is dead, right?
51:35 Chad
No, I'm, I'm-
51:35 Patrick
Yeah, they've acquired significant property to make that happen at some point. The question is just, when does the investment trigger get pulled on it? So securing land is... And finding private owners to secure that land, uh, when you don't have public investment funds to do it with, um, is, is very, very difficult to do. But I mean, when I was in the city of Bryan, I mean, I felt like we... I, I'd have to go back and check the numbers, but when we redeveloped downtown Bryan, I felt like the city owned, like, half of downtown by the time the redevelopment started. 'Cause they had to go in and just buy things up to clean it up, right? Now, downtown Bryan, I would say, is one of the prettiest downtown areas in the state of Texas. Very pretty. So, uh, next-
52:16 Chad
I need to go down there. I'll go to Bryan. I'll stay out of College Station.
52:20 Patrick
You. The LaSalle Hotel. The LaSalle Hotel was bought by the city of Bryan and redone, and now I think it's technically like a Magnolia Hotel, if I remember. But, um-
52:33 Chad
I feel like Greenville did that, too. South Carolina, I feel like they bought a hotel, and then-
52:39 Patrick
I mean, it wouldn't surprise me
52:40 Chad
... flipped it. I can't remember for sure.
52:42 Patrick
Yeah, but, uh, I, I mean, I, I, I do think, I think the... Downtowns are at, like, a very important part of, of who we are, and we can't really lose track of that as a community. And it does, I, I... It does strongly take an evangelical-style leader, whether that's your economic development, downtown director. Um, I mean, I, I'll just tell you from experience, because I live here and I go to some of their events, but, you know, downtown Waterford has been significantly transformed by the fact that they hired a, a downtown director who's, you know, very good. She's very good. So, you know, putting on events, and showcasing businesses, and having a social media following, and having an IG following, and all those different types of things that you have to have in today's world are extremely important. Uh-
53:29 Chad
Is it no longer called Insta?
53:32 Patrick
Uh, I don't think we... I think we call it the Gram-
53:34 Chad
I don't know
53:34 Patrick
... or IG.
53:35 Chad
I don't I don't-
53:36 Patrick
Yeah.
53:36 Chad
I doubt it's called the Gram.
53:38 Patrick
Yeah. I call it Insta.
53:39 Chad
I've, I've never been a, an Instagram user, so I don't know-
53:42 Patrick
Are you making fun of me, like, five years ago, calling it Insta?
53:45 Chad
That's what a lot of people were calling it. It's hard, though, because as you get older, you're always on the tail end of those trends.
53:52 Patrick
Okay.
53:52 Chad
So by the time it gets to you now, like at our age, it's already, like, washed through the younger kids.
53:59 Patrick
I will ask the high school principal what the correct per- term-
54:02 Chad
Okay
54:02 Patrick
... is now, and she'll, she'll let me know, and, and I'll let you I'll bring it back.
54:06 Chad
Please do. Follow up next time.
54:07 Patrick
Yeah. Um, you know about rizz?
54:10 Chad
I do know about rizz.
54:11 Patrick
Okay.
54:11 Chad
I'm full of rizz.
54:13 Patrick
Yeah. Wow. That was the most dad statement you could make. That was, that was bad. Um, yeah, I, I learn all about the new terminology. Usually, the, like, the first or second week of school, uh, at the dinner table, we'll go through all the new terms, both from the high school level, and the, uh, junior high, and the elementary, 'cause we have all three now in our family.
54:32 Chad
Mm-hmm.
54:33 Patrick
So yeah, it's, uh, it's quite entertaining for me to learn all the new words. And then, as a, an annoying dad, I use them at every opportunity I can that's not appropriate, so...
54:45 Chad
What good is being a dad if you can't embarrass your kids?
54:47 Patrick
Yeah, true. Speaking of embarrassing my kids, my kid had his first Valentine.
54:51 Chad
Oh, yeah?
54:52 Patrick
Yeah. The, um, the little girl who asked him to be his Valentine, which, you know, I'm such a traditional male, I, I had a problem with that. He should ask her. But, you know, it is what it is. Um, the ... the, the little girl who asked him, super, super, super sweet little girl, uh, wrote him a note, George, uh, Strait style. No, it'd be Tim McGraw, right? Check yes or no, it was Tim McGraw?
55:18 Chad
I believe so.
55:19 Patrick
Okay.
55:20 Chad
Uh, give me... You keep talking, I'll confirm.
55:23 Patrick
"Will you be my Valentine? Please check yes or check no." That, uh, that was the letter that he got, so-
55:30 Chad
What, what did he check?
55:32 Patrick
Yes. Yeah.
55:34 Chad
Check yes or no. George Strait.
55:37 Patrick
Yay!
55:37 Chad
You were right the first time.
55:37 Patrick
It was George.
55:39 Chad
Okay.
55:40 Patrick
So did I just- I think I just lost my Texas card-
55:43 Chad
I think so
55:44 Patrick
... by not knowing it was George.
55:44 Chad
And the fact that I, when you said-
55:46 Patrick
I said George first.
55:47 Chad
You did, but when you said Tim McGraw, I literally couldn't hear it, except in Tim McGraw's voice.
55:53 Patrick
Maybe Tim sings it louder.
55:54 Chad
That was the wildest thing.
55:55 Patrick
Yeah. Okay, well, I don't know. That was a very popular song when we were in-
55:59 Chad
Yeah
55:59 Patrick
... I'd say, like, junior high, right? It'd be in junior high.
56:01 Chad
It came out in '95.
56:03 Patrick
Yeah, so that's like elementary.
56:06 Chad
I think you're a year behind me, so you would've graduate- had gotten into sixth grade in the '94, '95 school year.
56:12 Patrick
Wow! The fact that you can do that math in your head is still impressive. I'm getting old. I need to go put my readers on right now.
56:18 Chad
Barely. Make sure you have your cane over there in the corner for when you get up.
56:21 Patrick
I'll tell you what, with the pretty pictures that my wife put on the wall in my office, if anybody's been on Zoom calls with me, you can tell I had nothing to do with these, but...
56:29 Chad
Uh, I had nothing to do with these, but I did put them up. They are-
56:34 Patrick
What are they?
56:34 Chad
... weird Star Wars, weird Star Wars characters, like-
56:38 Patrick
Just-
56:38 Chad
... in suits.
56:39 Patrick
'Cause that surprises nobody.
56:39 Chad
Like, this is Yoda, Yoda in a suit.
56:43 Patrick
Nice.
56:43 Chad
Pretty sure that's Darth Vader.
56:45 Patrick
Nice.
56:45 Chad
This is, this, this column is all of the, the dark side people.
56:51 Patrick
Okay.
56:51 Chad
And then this column is all of the light side people.
56:54 Patrick
In- interesting. Okay.
56:55 Chad
And then I did pick these out. I have eight, like, sort of retro-stylized, almost art deco-stylized posters of various cities.
57:04 Patrick
I can't with you. So anyways, I'm done with my downtown conversation. Do you have anything else?
57:10 Chad
No.
57:11 Patrick
Okay.
57:11 Chad
I'm good. I, I honestly didn't think that was gonna go for an hour, but hopefully it was worth it.
57:18 Patrick
Yeah, you know, let's get into it. General idea-
57:20 Chad
I guess I'll find out for sure once I start editing-
57:23 Patrick
Yeah, probably so
57:24 Chad
... if it was any good.
57:25 Patrick
Probably so. Yep. So, um, all right, that's all I've got, man. What do you- what else you got?
57:31 Chad
Cool.
57:31 Patrick
We have anything else to talk about?
57:32 Chad
I think we should probably cut it short here.
57:34 Patrick
Okay.
57:34 Chad
Well, not even short. I think we should cut it long.
57:36 Patrick
Okay, cut it.